Peer Review Guide (JIBES)

PART A: Editorial Office Only

 

SECTION I

 

Reviewer’s Name:

_____________________________________________________________

Email:

_____________________________________________________________

Manuscript Number:

_____________________________________________________________

Title:

_____________________________________________________________

Date Sent to Reviewer:

_____________________________________________________________

Date Expected from Reviewer:

_____________________________________________________________

 

PART B: Reviewer Only

 

SECTION II: Comments per Section of Manuscript

General comment:

_________________________________________________

Title (Concise and Informative):

_________________________________________________

Abstract (Up to 250 words):

_________________________________________________

Key Words (for indexing and database search):   

_________________________________________________

Introduction:

_________________________________________________

Materials and Methods:

_________________________________________________

Results:

_________________________________________________

Discussion:

_________________________________________________

Acknowledgements:

_________________________________________________

References:

_________________________________________________

 

 

 

SECTION III: Rating (1 = Excellent) (2 = Good) (3 = Fair) (4 = Poor)

 

Manuscript Originality:

_____________________________________________________________

Contribution to the Field:

_____________________________________________________________

Technical Quality:

_____________________________________________________________

Clarity of Presentation :

_____________________________________________________________

Scope of Research:

_____________________________________________________________

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SECTION IV: Recommendation (Mark with Î)

 

Accepted:

_____________________________________________________________

Requires Minor Corrections:

_____________________________________________________________

Requires Moderate Revision:

_____________________________________________________________

Requires Major Revision:

_____________________________________________________________

Rejected (Please Be Specific):

_____________________________________________________________

 

SECTION V: Additional Comments

Please add any additional comments (including comments/suggestions, if any)

______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________